About AK

Anatoly Karlin is a Director at Arctic Progress. He studied political economy at Berkeley, runs the popular Russia, geopolitics and peak oil blog Sublime Oblivion, and is a member of the Russian Arctic association Мой Север.

Exciting Stuff In The Works

Image credit – Desktop 3d.

No, we haven’t frozen solid in the Arctic wildernesses.

In fact, not only are we alive and kicking, but we have some pretty cool developments for ARCTIC PROGRESS in the works. Hence the lack of posting.

This Thursday, we are rolling out a special free subscription newsletter service for Arctic aficionados and amateurs alike. If you crave for the latest filtered news and cutting-edge commentary on this emerging region, then look no further – you won’t find it anywhere else.

In the meantime, the website is going to be radically reworked to a new theme and style. Regular blog posting will resume next week.

But all this is just the tip of the proverbial iceberg. In the next months, our expert team of writers and researchers will be transforming the Library here into the biggest repository of information resources on the Arctic in the world today. And even that isn’t all…

So watch out – the avalanche is just getting started!

AP Global Sitrep #5

In our latest Global Sitrep, we cover a US businessman making big $ in breakaway Abkhazia, PLUS Mubarak’s fall, AI development, China’s drought and Japan’s political deadlock.

Pharaoh Replaced, System Remains

1. ELLIS GOLDBERG for Foreign Policy, Feb 11, 2011: Mubarakism Without Mubarak

Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak gave into the demands of the protesters today, leaving Cairo and stepping down from power. That came hours after a speech, broadcast live across the world yesterday, in which he refused to do so. Earlier that day, the Supreme Military Council released a statement — labeled its “first” communiqué — that stated that the military would ensure a peaceful transition of Mubarak out of office. In practice, it appears that power has passed into the hands of the armed forces. This act was the latest in the military’s creep from applauded bystander to steering force in this month’s protests in Egypt. Since the protest movement first took shape on January 25, the military has, with infinite patience, extended and deepened its physical control of the area around Tahrir Square (the focal point of the protests) with concrete barriers, large steel plates, and rolls of razor wire. In itself, the military’s growing footprint was the next act in a slow-motion coup — a return of the army from indirect to direct control — the groundwork for which was laid in 1952.

The West may be worried that the crisis will bring democracy too quickly to Egypt and empower the Muslim Brotherhood. But the real concern is that the regime will only shed its corrupt civilians, leaving its military component as the only player left standing. Indeed, when General Omar Suleiman, the recently appointed vice president to whom Mubarak entrusted presidential powers last night, threatened on February 9 that the Egyptian people must choose between either the current regime or a military coup, he only increased the sense that the country was being held hostage.

AK – Two quick comments.

First, this is no real “democratic” revolution (as per the anti-Communist revolutions of the late 1980′s) nor is it an Islamic revival. The generals remain in control. Nasser’s military coup of 1952 in Egypt’s own history is the best model.

Second – no, regardless of speculation in Western and liberal Russia media outlets, the probability of something similar playing out in Russia is next to non-existent. Soaring food prices were the main cause of the unrest both in Tunisia and Egypt. Russia is more or less self-sufficient in food (and a net grain exporter), whereas Egypt imports 40% of its food (and 60% of its wheat), and the average Russian is about 3 times richer than the average Egyptian. As such, Egypt is far more vulnerable to fluctuations in international food prices.

And we don’t even have to go into facts such as that the demonstrated popularity of Russia’s leaders – both Medvedev and Putin retain approval ratings of more than 70% in opinion polls…

Towards Artilects

BRIAN CHRISTIAN for The Atlantic, March 2011: Mind vs. Machine

… I wake up in a hotel room 5,000 miles from my home in Seattle. After breakfast, I step out into the salty air and walk the coastline of the country that invented my language, though I find I can’t understand a good portion of the signs I pass on my way—LET AGREED, one says, prominently, in large print, and it means nothing to me.

I pause, and stare dumbly at the sea for a moment, parsing and reparsing the sign. Normally these kinds of linguistic curiosities and cultural gaps intrigue me; today, though, they are mostly a cause for concern. In two hours, I will sit down at a computer and have a series of five-minute instant-message chats with several strangers. At the other end of these chats will be a psychologist, a linguist, a computer scientist, and the host of a popular British technology show. Together they form a judging panel, evaluating my ability to do one of the strangest things I’ve ever been asked to do.

I must convince them that I’m human.

Fortunately, I am human; unfortunately, it’s not clear how much that will help.

Promise of Abkhazia

HALEY SWEETLAND EDWARDS for The Atlantic, March 2011: Boca on the Black Sea

THE REAL-ESTATE developer doesn’t seem to see the bullet holes in the cement wall behind him. Or the mortar-scarred apartment buildings. Or the half-bombed mansions where trees sprout through wallpapered living rooms. All the real-estate developer seems to see in Abkhazia, this breakaway territory wedged between Georgia and Russia along the Black Sea, is opportunity.

“This place could be the Florida of the Caucasus,” Bruce Talley says, jabbing my arm with excitement as we walk between two filthy concrete hotels. Gorbachev, Khrushchev, and Stalin all built vacation homes in the area, their porches overlooking a string of empty beaches, turquoise water, and looming mountains that tinge peach at sunset. “This is the ideal subtropical paradise for 145 million Russians, and there is nowhere for them to stay.”

АК – We consider Abkhazian real estate one of the best medium-term investments on Earth today. The situation there is likely the Balkan coastal regions in 2000. Political stability in the region has been restored, but mainstream investors are still too deterred by the recent past. But by 2010 the new resorts in places like Montenegro are flourishing – and the “crazy” developers who took the plunge a decade ago are now  sitting on big fat wads of cash.

China’s Drought Grinds On

JONATHAN WYATT for The Guardian, Feb 11, 2011: China bids to ease drought with $1bn emergency water aid

China has announced a billion dollars in emergency water aid to ease its most severe drought in 60 years, as the United Nations warned of a threat to the harvest of the world’s biggest wheat producer.

Beijing has also promised to use its grain reserves to reduce the pressure on global food prices, which have surged in the past year to record highs due to the floods in Australia and a protracted dry spell in Russia.

Scandal!

LEE FANG for Think Progress, Feb 10, 2011: US Chamber’s Lobbyists Solicited Hackers To Sabotage Unions, Smear Chamber’s Political Opponents

ThinkProgress has learned that a law firm representing the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the big business trade association representing ExxonMobil, AIG, and other major international corporations, is working with set of “private security” companies and lobbying firms to undermine their political opponents, including ThinkProgress, with a surreptitious sabotage campaign.

Japan’s Deadlock

TODD CROWELL for Real Clear World, Feb 11, 2011: Is Japan Headed for Government Shutdown?

TOKYO – If you think that President Barack Obama has trouble with gridlock in Congress, consider the position of Japan’s Prime Minister Naoto Kan. All the elements of gridlock are in place: a divided legislature, an opposition bent on obstruction, falling approval ratings and a stagnant economy. Sound familiar?

If Kan’s Democratic Party of Japan cannot pass the fiscal 2011 budget and related money bills by March 31, specifically legislation enabling the government to issue bonds needed to finance itself, Tokyo could be looking at a $400 billion revenue shortfall. Roughly half of the budget is covered through borrowing.

One might wonder how a party with a more than 150-seat majority in the House of Representatives, the lower chamber of Japan’s bicameral parliament, could have such trouble getting its way. If Japan were Britain, with its weak upper chamber the House of Lords, this wouldn’t be the case.

Bright Conclusions From Latest Arctic Sea Ice Melt Research

But other models project ice-free Arctic summers from as early as 2013. Image credit – NASA.

It is considered that the melting of the Arctic sea ice is a runaway process – once it vanishes during a summer, it is unlikely to ever reappear during that season. That is because far more heat is going to be absorbed by the dark ocean water, preventing the reformation of the white, high-albedo sea ice that would have otherwise cooled itself.

However, a research team at the Max Planck Institute for Meteorology, Germany, have challenged this pessimistic prognosis. They point out that though the Sun will warm the ocean more strongly in the summer months, the lack of the ice blanket will likewise cause the ocean to lose heat to the atmosphere more quickly during the dark winter months. Therefore, one ice-free summer will not necessarily be the tipping point that leads to another and another.

STEFFEN TIETSCHE ET AL. for Geophysical Research Letters, 2011: Recovery mechanisms of Arctic summer sea ice.

We examine the recovery of Arctic sea ice from prescribed ice-free summer conditions in simulations of 21st century climate in an atmosphere–ocean general circulation model. We find that ice extent recovers typically within two years.

The excess oceanic heat that had built up during the ice-free summer is rapidly returned to the atmosphere during the following autumn and winter, and then leaves the Arctic partly through increased longwave emission at the top of the atmosphere and partly through reduced atmospheric heat advection from lower latitudes. Oceanic heat transport does not contribute significantly to the loss of the excess heat.

Our results suggest that anomalous loss of Arctic sea ice during a single summer is reversible, as the ice–albedo feedback is alleviated by large-scale recovery mechanisms. Hence, hysteretic threshold behavior (or a “tipping point”) is unlikely to occur during the decline of Arctic summer sea-ice cover in the 21st century.

Read more at Geophysical Research Letters.

Russia To Militarize Kurils In Response To Japanese Claims

Atlasov Island, northernmost of the Kurils. Image credit – Wikipedia.

This week has seen rising tensions over the Kuril Islands in the Russian Far East, which are claimed by Japan. There was heated rhetoric from senior Japanese politicians and the burning of a Russian flag on Feb 7th at a Japanese protest over Russian officials’ visits to the territories, including that of President Medvedev last November. This spurred a Russian youth group to picket the Japanese Embassy in Moscow.

On Feb 9th, President Medvedev held a meeting with the Defense Minister and the Minister for Regional Development, giving instructions to improve regional defense capacities into order to guarantee Russian sovereignty over the Kurils.

A source in the Defense Ministry told RIA Novosti that the first two of the four Mistral helicopter carriers that Russia has acquired from France are to be deployed to the Pacific Fleet. This is to be accompanied by modernization of the regional 18th Division, and the addition of two S-400 “Triumf” SAM divisions, self-propelled Pantsyr-S1 air defense systems, several modern radar stations, and a Bastion P coastal defense system armed with Yakhont anti-ship missiles. Afterwards there are plans to construct an air base on the islands, with Su-35 fighters and anti-submarine aircraft.

Nonetheless, as noted by Nikolai Tulaev, a member of the Federation Council on Defense and Security, even after the military upgrades the Kurils will remain far less militarized than under the Soviet period.

On Jan 25 this year, France and Russia signed a $1.9 billion agreement signed to sell two of the Mistral helicopter carriers to the Russian Navy and build another two under French license. The vessels can carry up to 16 helicopters, 450 troops, and 40 tanks or other heavy vehicles. The first Mistral is due to be deliver by year-end 2013. Image credit – Defense Industry Daily.

Soviet troops seized the four Kurils islands near Hokkaido as part of military operations against Japan at the end of World War Two. This reversed the Russian Empire’s cession of South Sakhalin to Japan in the treaty following its defeat in the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-5

We acknowledge that many borders disputes are highly complex. But for a variety of legal and practical reasons, Arctic Progress believes that the case of the Kurils is about as clear cut as they come.

First, in the purely legal sense, Japan had officially forsworn any future claims to the Kurils in the 1951 Treaty of San Francisco.

Second, Japan refused a Russian standing offer from the 1990′s to 2005 to take two of the four islands as part of a final peace settlement. This offer is unlikely to ever reappear. In the “time of troubles” following the Soviet collapse, Russia was an impoverished former superpower; a state whose writ was barely felt on its Pacific seaboard. Now it is flush with oil money, in stark contrast to Japan’s chronic budget deficits and 220%-of-GDP debt. Japan has far less to offer Russia than a decade ago.

Map of the Kurils: Japan wants all four held since the start of diplomatic relations with Russia in 1855; Russia was once willing to offer Shikotan and the Habomai Islands. Image credit – Wikipedia.

Third, surrendering the Kurils would undermine one of the main pillars of the global postwar order – the principle that the territorial changes of World War Two are irreversible. Challenging this principle would open up a whole can of worms not only in Russia, but around the world – Italy and western Slovenia; Germany and Polish Silesia and the Danzig Corridor; etc. And why not? Japan might as well demand back Karafuto, the southern half of Sakhalin it seized in 1905 and lost again in 1945.

Fourth, Russia’s elites have sunk far too much political capital into asserting Russia’s sovereignty over the Kurils in the past few years – culminating in President Medvedev’s visit to the islands in November 2010. This is in addition to the near-universal public opposition against giving back the Kurils to Japan. Territorial concessions will be politically suicidal.

We can state with some certainty that the Kurils will remain Russia for the foreseeable future. The continued Japanese attempts to argue otherwise are most likely a play to popular sentiment under their unstable political situation, and not a realistic appraisal of its foreign policy interests.

Iceland Volcanoes May Soon Vent Their Fury Again

Bardarbunga Volcano, Iceland. Image credit – Geographic.com.

The Telegraph, Feb 8, 2011.

Geologists detected the high risk of a new eruption after evaluating an increased swarm of earthquakes around the island’s second largest volcano.

Pall Einarsson, a professor of geophysics at the University of Iceland, says the area around Bárdarbunga is showing signs of increased activity, which provides “good reason to worry”.

But he said there was “every reason to worry” as the sustained earthquake tremors to the north east of the remote volcano range are the strongest recorded in recent times and there was “no doubt” the lava was rising.

Read more at The Telegraph.

AK – But don’t cancel your cross-Atlantic flights or start hoarding cans and ammo just yet. Other volcano watchers argue seismic tremors happen regularly and don’t imply imminent eruptions, and that the British press has sensationalized this news.

Northern Sea Route Shipping To Multiply Fivefold In 2011

The 41,000-ton MV Nordic Barents which was the first foreign-flagged vessel to pass through the Northern Sea Route without stopping at a Russian port.

Barents Observer, Feb 11, 2011.

The several successful shipping operations in 2010 are now making shipping companies look at the Northern Sea Route with increasing interest. According to Nord News, at least 150,000 tons of oil are planned shipped from Murmansk to China. In addition, there are plans for about 400,000 tons of gas condensate and 600,000 tons of iron ore to be sent along the same route.

The first shipment of gas condensate will be made already in May this year from the port of Vitino, Nord News reports. Most likely, Sovcomflot’s 70,000 ton ice-protected tankers “Kirill Lavrov” and “Vasilii Dinkov” will conduct the operations. Another two such operations are planned later in summer.

Read more at Barents Observer.

AK – Last year, about 0.25 million tons of oil, gas condensate and iron ore were shipped through the Northern Sea Route. This year the figure will be at least 1.15 million tons. Though this is still a globally insignificant figure – the world’s busiest ports handle up to 500 million tons of cargo annually – the true promise of Arctic shipping rises in its exponential growth rates.

We cannot emphasize enough how important gaining exposure to soon-to-be-privatized Sovcomflot and the Port of Murmansk is going to be for Arctic-minded investors.

From Russia To Canada, With Passage Over Pole

Satellite map of the Arctic. Image credit – Marine Science Today.

THOMAS GROVE for Reuters, Feb 8, 2011.

MOSCOW (Reuters) – A Russian-led expedition aims to make the first ever crossing from Russia’s Arctic shore into Canada over the North Pole, a months-long voyage over precarious shifting ice floes.

The expedition, set to begin on February 17, will serve for some of the first tests of Russia’s GLONASS satellite navigation technology, Moscow’s bid to challenge the dominant U.S. global positioning system (GPS). …

The 8,000-km (5,000-mile) voyage is expected to reach Canada by the end of May and finish by June 22, he said.

Eight explorers will set out in two specially-designed vehicles with overinflated tyres that allow for travel over the snowdrifts and dangerous Arctic ice cap, where above-freezing temperatures in the summer months can cause the ice to break up.

Read more at Reuters.

H/t Mark Sleboda for the article.

Iceberg Cornucopia

If you have a burning interest, or even a passing curiosity, in icebergs – then you’ve come to the right page!

“LADY TRIGGER” for Trigger Pit, Feb 7, 2011.

Icebergs are large pieces of ice that broke off from a snow-formed glacier or an iceshelf. Where a glacier meets the sea, humongous chunks of ice break off from the face of the glacier; this is known as “calving”and this is how many icebergs are “born.” Old icebergs may be hundreds of thousands of years old. Many years of falling snow, consisting of snow crystals by the countless billions, act like tiny mirrors and reflect the light. Some icebergs are also formed by freezing ocean water instead of snow and those areas are full of tiny air bubbles. Beautiful bluish streaks that appear in some icebergs are caused by the refreezing of meltwater that previously filled very old glacier ice crevasses. The very dense, very old ice captures the sun’s light and allows only the high-energy blue wavelengths to escape. The beautiful blue icebergs change color and intensity according to the position of the sun.

Click here for the full 37 photos.

Ice calving at Glaciar Perito Moreno, Argentina Christof Berger

Colorful iceberg with blue stripe Jeff McNeill

Steve Irwin iceberg John (guano)

Frozen tidal wave Hoax Slayer

Danmark O, Fohn Fjord, Renodde – iceberg Rita Willaert

Blue ice at South Polar circle Antarktika

See more iceberg pics here!

Finland Cooperates With Russia On Arctic Development

“Finland’s Foreign Minister Alexander Stubb in Russia’s Arctic capital Murmansk.” Image credit – Barents Observer.

THOMAS NILSEN for Barents Observer, Feb 10, 2011.

Finland wants to place itself as a key-player in the Arctic; establishment of EU’s Arctic info-centre to Rovaniemi, holding Arctic Summit this year; develop its infrastructure towards Arctic Oceans and this week initiates political and economical ties with Russia in the Arctic.

Speaking about “Finnish-Russian Arctic Partnership” in St. Petersburg this week; Foreign Minister Alexander Stubb said the cooperation with Russia should be free from red tape. …

The Finnish Foreign Minister also suggested to work together with Russian on marketing the Northern Sea Route.

Russia’s high-profiled Arctic explorer Arthur Chilingarov followed up on Alexander Stubb’s speech by launching the idea to set up a joint Finnish – Russian shipbuilding enterprise. Such enterprise can build high-tech Arctic vessels.

Read more at Barents Observer.

Thorvald Stoltenberg First Honorary Doctor Of The Arctic University

Arkhangelsk State Technical University will form the core of Russia’s new Northern Federal “Arctic University.” Image credit – Wikipedia.

TRUDE PETTERSEN for Barents Observer, Feb 10, 2011.

The former minister of foreign affairs in 1993 formalized the ground-breaking cooperation initiative together with Russian, Finnish and Swedish counterparts.

The ceremony takes place in Arkhangelsk on February 15.

The Northern (Arctic) Federal University of Arkhangelsk was established in 2010 when the two biggest state universities in Arkhangelsk – The Technical University and the Pomor University were merged into one structure with a high level of autonomy and lavish federal financing.

Read more at Barents Observer.

AK – Thorvald Stoltenberg is considered as a “grand old man” of Norwegian politics and is a strong proponent of greater Nordic security cooperation. In our recent coverage of the Wikileaks cables, the US ambassador to Oslo described some of his more ambitious ideas as “dreams in polar fog.”